Picking a realtor is one of the first real decisions a first-time buyer makes, and it's also one of the easiest to rush — a friend's referral, the agent from a Zillow listing, whoever responds fastest. Dillar Schwartz, from The Dillar Group, believes this choice deserves more intention than that, because the right agent genuinely changes outcomes, including what gets found, how negotiations go, and how smoothly closing actually happens.
Questions Worth Asking Before Hiring Anyone
A short conversation reveals a lot. Asking how many transactions an agent closed in the past year, and specifically how many involved first-time buyers, tells you whether this is someone who regularly works with buyers in a similar situation or someone whose experience leans elsewhere — luxury, investment properties, listings. Asking which neighborhoods or price bands they work in most often matters too; an agent deeply familiar with 400K–600K first-time-buyer inventory in specific ZIP codes brings different value than one who mostly works $1.5M+ listings.
It's also worth asking directly how they handle multiple-offer situations and what their general negotiating approach looks like — the answer reveals whether they default to cautious or assertive, and whether that style matches what a buyer actually wants in a competitive moment.
Red Flags Worth Taking Seriously
An agent who pushes toward a specific lender, inspector, or title company without explaining why, or who seems reluctant to let a buyer compare options, is worth a closer look — Texas law requires certain disclosures around referral relationships, and a transparent agent explains those connections rather than glossing over them. Similarly, an agent who discourages questions, rushes a buyer toward an offer, or seems more interested in closing quickly than finding the right fit is a signal worth noticing early rather than after signing a buyer representation agreement.
Response time during the interview phase is also a preview of what working together will actually feel like — an agent who's slow to respond before being hired rarely becomes faster afterward.
Understanding Buyer Representation Agreements
Since 2024, buyers in most of the country are generally expected to sign a written buyer representation agreement before touring homes with an agent, a shift from how things worked historically. This agreement spells out the agent's compensation, the length of the representation period, and the scope of what they're agreed to help with. It's worth reading this document carefully rather than signing it quickly — asking about the compensation structure, the agreement's length, and what happens if the relationship isn't working out are all fair, expected questions.
"A good first-time buyer agent explains things you didn't know to ask about. A mediocre one just answers the questions you happen to think of."
Local Knowledge That Actually Matters
Beyond general experience, an agent's specific familiarity with Austin's particular quirks — the option period process, common inspection issues in Central Texas homes, which neighborhoods carry MUD or PID taxes, current lender buy-down programs — meaningfully shapes how smoothly a first-time purchase goes. An agent who can explain these concepts clearly, without jargon, in the first conversation is generally a good sign of how they'll communicate throughout the rest of the process.
The Dillar Group recently worked with a first-time buyer who had initially interviewed an agent recommended by a coworker, but found the conversation left several basic questions about the option period and closing costs unanswered. A second interview with a different agent, who walked through the entire process clearly and proactively, made the choice obvious — the buyer went with the agent who explained things before being asked.
What a Good Fit Actually Feels Like
The right agent for a first-time buyer isn't necessarily the most experienced or the most well-known — it's someone who communicates clearly, explains unfamiliar terms without being asked twice, and seems genuinely invested in finding the right home rather than closing the fastest deal. A short initial conversation, treated as a real interview rather than a formality, usually reveals this fairly quickly.
Communication Style Matters More Than It Seems
Beyond credentials, it's worth paying attention to how an agent actually communicates during the interview itself — whether they explain things in plain language or lean on jargon, whether they ask questions about a buyer's actual goals and timeline, and whether they seem comfortable saying "I don't know, but I'll find out" rather than guessing. First-time buyers in particular benefit from an agent who treats basic questions as normal rather than a sign of inexperience, since nearly every first-time buyer has the same foundational questions regardless of how the interview conversation is framed.
If you're starting your search and want to talk through what to look for, The Dillar Group is happy to have that conversation. Schedule a buyer interview.